Investors will learn today whether the Paulson bail-out - fattened to $850bn (likely to fetch $1.8 trillion) by Congress - can begin to halt the death spiral in the credit
system. So far, the response looks terrible.
Germany is now in the hot seat. The collapse of a rescue deal for Hypo Real
Estate on Saturday threatens a €400bn bankruptcy that nearly
matches the Lehman Brothers debacle for sheer scale.
Chancellor Angela Merkel has been forced to pull her head out of the sand,
guaranteeing all German savings, a day after she rebuked Ireland for doing
much the same thing. Reality hurts.
During the past week, we have tipped over the edge, into the middle of the
abyss. Systemic collapse is in full train. The Netherlands has just rushed
through a second, more sweeping nationalisation of Fortis. Ireland and
specifically Greece's kindergarten economy have had to rescue all their banks. Iceland is facing an Argentine
denouement.
The US commercial paper market is closed. It shrank $95bn last week, and has
lost $208bn in three weeks. The interbank lending market has seized up.
There are almost no bids. It is a ghost market. Healthy companies cannot
roll over debt. Some will have to sack staff today to stave off default.
As the unflappable Warren Buffett puts it, the credit freeze is “sucking
blood” out of the economy. “In my adult lifetime, I don’t think I’ve ever
seen people as fearful,” he said.
We are fast approaching the point of no return. The only way out of this
calamitous descent is “shock and awe” on a global scale, and even that may
not be enough.
Drastic rate cuts would be a good start. Central bankers still paralysed by a
misplaced fear of inflation – whether in Europe, Britain, or the US – have
become a public menace and should be held to severe account by our
democracies. The imminent and massive danger is now self-feeding debt
deflation.
The lesson of the 1930s is that any country trying to reflate in isolation
will be punished. The crisis will ricochet from one economy to another until
every one is crippled. We are seeing it play again in this drama as our
leaders fail to rise above their narrow, parochial agendas.
The European Central Bank – which raised rates into the teeth of the crisis
in July – has played a shockingly destructive role in this enveloping
slump. Its growth predictions this year have been, and still are,
delusional. Neglecting its global role, it has vastly complicated the
fire-fighting efforts of Washington.
It could have offered “cover” to the US Federal Reserve this spring when Ben
Bernanke was forced by events to slash rates to 2pc. It could at least have
signalled an end to monetary tightening. That is how an ally ought to
behave.
Instead, it stuck maniacally to its Gothic script, with equally unhappy
consequences for both sides of the Atlantic, as well as for China, Japan,
and India. The euro rocketed yet further, which it turn set off an oil shock
as crude metamorphosed into an anti-dollar with leverage.
The ECB policy was self-defeating, even on its own terms. It merely drove
headline inflation even higher, while deeper forces of underlying debt
deflation pulled the real economies of Germany, Italy, France, and Spain
into a recessionary vortex.
Far from offering reassurance, the weekend mini-summit of EU leaders served
only to highlight that nobody is in charge of this runaway train. There is
still no lender of last resort in euroland. The $22bn stimulus package is
risible.
Angela Merkel has revealed her deep limitations. It was she who vetoed French
efforts to launch a pan-EU rescue package, suspecting that any lifeboat fund
would prove to be Trojan Horse – a way of co-opting German taxpayers into
colossal transfers of wealth to Latin Europe.
In that she is right, but it is too late now for dysfunctional EU political
games. By demanding that those who caused the damage should pay for it, she
crossed the line into caricature, or worse.
Her comments echo word for word the “we’re alright Jack” attitudes of
Euro-pols during the first US banking crises in 1930-1931, until the storm
hit Europe and the entire cast was swept away by furious electorates, or
simply shot. Thankfully, this EU stupidity is at last drawing serious
criticism.
“We have to make sure Europe takes its responsibilities, like the US: action
must be taken quickly and in a concerted manner,” said IMF chief Dominique
Strauss-Kahn.
As for the US itself, it has not yet exhausted its policy arsenal. It can
escalate further up the nuclear ladder. The Fed can cut interest rates from
2pc to zero. If that fails, it can let rip with the mass purchase of US
debt.
“The US government has a technology, called a printing press,” said Fed chief
Ben Bernanke in November 2002. (His helicopter speech).
In extremis, the Treasury/Fed can swoop into any market to shore up asset
prices. They can buy Florida property. They can even buy SUV guzzlers from
the car lots in Detroit, and mangle them in scrap yards. As Bernanke put
it, the Fed can “expand the menu of assets that it buys.”
There is a devilish catch to this ploy, of course. It assumes that foreign
creditors will tolerate such action.
Japan entered its Lost Decade as the world’s top creditor, with a vast pool of
household savings to cushion the slump. America starts its purge with net
external liabilities of $3 trillion, and a savings rate near zero.
Foreigners own over half the US Treasury debt, and two thirds of all Fannie,
Freddie, and other US agency bonds.
But the risk of a dollar collapse is one for the distant future. Right now the
world faces the opposite problem. There is a wild scramble for dollars as a
$10 trillion pyramid of global lending based on dollar balance sheets
“delevers” with a vengeance.
This is a “short squeeze” on those who have used the dollar for a vast global
carry trade. International banks are facing margin calls on their dollar
leverage. It is why the Fed is having to provide $1.25 trillion in dollar
liquidity for the entire global system, according to estimates by Brad
Setser from the Center for Geoeconomic Studies.
The crisis engulfing Europe, Asia and emerging markets, makes life easier for
Washington. The United States is becoming a safe-haven again.
The Fed can now hope to pursue monetary stimulus “a l’outrance” without being
slapped down by the currency, debt, and commodity markets. Take comfort
where you can. //07.10.08 //Emanuel Williams
|